top of page
Search

Something Has Gone Terribly Wrong Here

Writer: lisa62143
lisa62143
Oct 3
15 min read

Family Estrangement, Therapy Culture, and a Mental-Health Epidemic We Are Afraid to Name



By Lisa Franco Alexander


There is an anger building in places most people never see. It is not the kind of anger that arrives suddenly, burns hot for an afternoon, and disappears. It is the anger that comes after months or years of trying to understand how the people you loved became people you are no longer permitted to know. It is grief mixed with disbelief, and beneath both of them is a question that many parents seem almost afraid to ask aloud: Am I the only one who thinks something much larger is happening here?


It lives inside private Facebook groups with twenty thousand members. Thirty thousand. Sometimes more. It appears beneath articles about family estrangement, in support communities for parents who have lost adult children and grandchildren, and in conversations among people who never imagined they would one day need a vocabulary for grieving someone who is still alive. These are mothers and fathers sitting at kitchen tables, lying awake in dark bedrooms, scrolling on phones after everyone else has gone to sleep, searching for some explanation that makes sense of a loss for which there was no funeral, no obituary, and often no clear ending.


Spend enough time in these spaces and the similarities become difficult to ignore. You begin recognizing the language before you even recognize the story. A different mother writes it. Then a father. Then a grandmother. Then someone who says she spent thirty years working in behavioral health. Different families. Different states. Different childhoods. Different circumstances. Yet the same words appear again and again: Narcissist. Toxic. Trauma. Unsafe. Gaslighting. Boundaries. Protecting my peace. No contact.


And thousands of parents are asking some version of the same bewildered question: What the hell happened to us?


It is a raw question, and I think we make a mistake when we hear only the anger inside it. There is heartbreak there, too. There is the shock of discovering that the vocabulary being used to explain your family may be completely different from the vocabulary with which you lived it. There is also something terribly lonely about realizing that the person explaining you may know only the version of you carried into a therapy room, typed into a social-media post, or repeated in a conversation you will never hear.


These aren't all parents who reject psychology. That would make this conversation much easier to dismiss. Some of them are psychologists. Therapists. Behavioral-health professionals. Social workers. Attorneys. Educators. Nurses. Professors. People who have spent careers studying human behavior, development, families, ethics, evidence and relationships. They have sat on the other side of desks. They have studied the terminology. Some have taught it. Some have spent their professional lives asking people to look honestly at themselves.


They aren't all standing outside psychology throwing rocks at it. Some are standing inside the profession saying: I know this language. I know what these concepts were supposed to mean. And what I am watching happen scares the hell out of me. That deserves our attention.


The Parents Are Talking. Is Anyone Listening?


Facebook comments are not scientific studies. Twenty thousand members in an estrangement group do not mean twenty thousand people share an identical explanation for their estrangement. Nobody should pretend otherwise, and I certainly will not. But there is an enormous difference between saying that these accounts cannot establish prevalence and pretending that thousands upon thousands of people independently describing similar experiences have nothing important to tell us.


But that does not make their experiences meaningless. Their words tell us what this loss feels like from inside it. They tell us what parents believe they are hearing from their children, what frightens them, what they do not understand, and what they believe has changed. If we want to understand family estrangement as a human phenomenon rather than merely a collection of statistics, surely the people living inside it deserve to be heard.


Across enormous online communities devoted to parental estrangement, parents publicly describe remarkably similar feelings: bewilderment at psychological labels they say have been attached to them; adult children describing childhood events through language the parents barely recognize; therapists allegedly offering opinions about parents they have never met; boundaries that parents say eventually became complete cutoff; and grandchildren disappearing along with their adult children.


There is something haunting about reading those accounts one after another. A mother may be grieving a daughter. Another may be grieving her only son. A grandfather may be trying to understand why he has not seen his grandchildren in years. Their family histories may have almost nothing else in common, yet the emotional bewilderment can sound eerily familiar. They are not simply saying, My child is angry with me. Many are saying, I no longer understand the framework through which my entire life as a parent is being judged.


These accounts cannot establish causation or prevalence. But they are a human record of what people say is happening to them. We should be capable of holding both truths at once. Their stories are not controlled research, and their stories still matter.


And research does not work backward: something does not become real only after somebody receives funding to measure it. Research often begins because enough human beings keep reporting something that somebody finally asks whether it should be measured. That is beginning to happen here.


Psychologists themselves now acknowledge the extraordinary migration of clinical terminology into ordinary life. The American Psychological Association has devoted discussion to the rise of “therapy-speak” and specifically to words such as gaslighting, narcissism and boundaries becoming part of the everyday vocabulary through which millions of people understand friends, families and relationships. (apa.org)


Academic literature now examines the same phenomenon. Researchers describe sophisticated psychological concepts being reduced to social-media-sized explanations, sometimes extending terminology beyond its intended meaning. Clinical words can become something entirely different when compressed into thirty-second videos and passed from therapist to influencer to algorithm to viewer to family argument. (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)

There is even a name for part of this phenomenon: concept creep—the expansion of harm-related concepts to encompass broader and sometimes less severe experiences. That matters when the subject is family. Because words don't merely describe relationships. Sometimes they determine what we believe those relationships are.


A word can change the way an old memory feels. A label can organize twenty years of complicated experiences into one seemingly simple explanation. Once a person has been placed into a category—toxic, narcissistic, unsafe—everything that came before can begin to be reinterpreted through that category. The loving moments do not necessarily disappear, but they can become harder to reconcile with the new story. Human beings who were once complicated can become remarkably simple.


The Generation That Had Parents, Too


There is something else I hear repeatedly from estranged parents of my generation. We had parents, too. They made mistakes.


Some were emotionally unavailable. Some were authoritarian. Some couldn't apologize. Some believed children should be seen and not heard. Some had no idea how to discuss feelings because nobody had ever discussed feelings with them. Some hurt us. Some disappointed us profoundly. And many of us deliberately raised our own children differently because of it.


We read the parenting books that existed then. We tried to say I love you more often. We hugged more. We listened more. We drove to practices, sat through games, helped with homework, worked ridiculous hours, worried about whether we were doing enough and promised ourselves that certain things from our own childhoods would stop with us. Did we succeed perfectly? Of course not. No generation ever has.


But there was a distinction many people in our generation understood almost instinctively: Someone could hurt you without becoming a harmful person. A parent could fail you without becoming your enemy. A relationship could contain conflict without being toxic. A mother could say something insensitive without being a narcissist. A father could remember an event differently without necessarily gaslighting you. A childhood could contain pain without every painful memory becoming evidence that the entire childhood was traumatic.


That did not mean pretending nothing happened. It did not mean that cruelty should be excused or that serious harm should be renamed love simply because it came from family. It meant that we understood something about human beings that seems increasingly difficult to express without immediately being misunderstood: people can be deeply imperfect and still be deeply loved.


Family relationships required something increasingly absent from the language surrounding relationships today: the capacity to hold two truths about another human being at once. You loved me. You hurt me. You tried. You failed me sometimes. You gave me things I treasure. You left me with things I had to overcome. You were my parent. You were human. Those sentences once coexisted. Increasingly, estranged parents say they feel as though they no longer can.


Perhaps that is part of what makes this particular grief so disorienting. Many estranged parents are not demanding to be declared flawless. They know they weren't. They can name things they wish they had done differently. What stuns them is the idea that imperfection itself may now be presented as evidence that the relationship is unsafe, irreparable, or undeserving of another conversation.


The Professionals Raising the Alarm


This isn't merely disgruntled parents complaining that their children went to therapy. Clinical psychologist Joshua Coleman, who has spent decades working with estranged families and trains other therapists, has become increasingly outspoken about the role therapeutic culture can play in family estrangement.


Other clinicians are asking similar questions. Rachel Haack, LMFT, has written about what happens when accountability becomes control and when therapy culture reduces complex family relationships into increasingly rigid categories of offender and victim.


Peter H. Anderson, LMFT, is particularly interesting because he occupies several worlds simultaneously: family therapist, estrangement specialist and professor. His work addresses estrangement, conflict and reconciliation, and he is examining the relationships among culture, therapy, social media, boundaries and family obligation.


This matters. Because a parent can be dismissed as bitter. A Facebook group can be dismissed as an echo chamber. A generation can be dismissed as old-fashioned. It becomes harder to dismiss the question when professionals inside the field itself begin asking whether something has gone wrong.


That last distinction matters enormously to me. These are not people who wandered into a Facebook group yesterday, learned the word gaslighting, and decided they were experts. Some have spent decades inside the very professions now shaping the language of estrangement. They understand that psychological concepts have definitions, that ethical practice has limits, and that families are systems containing histories and perspectives that cannot always be reduced to one person's account.


And some researchers are now looking directly at the language. Clinical psychologist and university professor Crissa Draper directs research examining loneliness and estrangement and the relationship between popularized psychological concepts—including words such as trauma, gaslighting and boundaries—and contemporary well-being and relationships.

The question is no longer whether therapy-speak exists. It does. (apa.org) The question is what it is doing to us.


And perhaps we need another question beside it: what happens when the language of psychology becomes culturally powerful faster than our ability to understand how that language is being used? A word learned in graduate school can carry nuance, diagnostic limitations, context and professional responsibility. The same word on social media can become a verdict.


The Person Who Isn't in the Room


There may be no experience more maddening to an estranged parent than hearing: My therapist says you're a narcissist. Or: My therapist helped me understand that you traumatized me. Or: My therapist agrees that you're toxic.

The parent sits there thinking: Your therapist has never met me.


Imagine what that feels like for a moment. Someone whose education and professional title carry enormous authority may—or may not—have helped form a judgment about your personality, your motives, your parenting or your entire relationship with your child. You don't know exactly what was said. You don't know what preceded it. You don't know whether your child used the clinician's exact words. Yet those words can arrive in your life carrying the weight of professional authority.


Perhaps the therapist never actually said those things. Perhaps something more nuanced was discussed and later condensed into those words. Perhaps the terminology came from social media rather than the therapy room. That uncertainty is itself part of the problem.

Because the parent isn't in the room. The parent doesn't know what was said. The parent doesn't know what information was presented. The parent cannot provide context. The parent cannot correct a factual error. The parent cannot know whether a psychological label actually came from a licensed clinician, an influencer, a friend, TikTok, ChatGPT or the adult child's own interpretation.


Yet the parent may experience the consequences as though a verdict has already been entered.


I keep thinking of them as Parent Does.


People whose identities can be discussed without their participation. People who sometimes believe they have been psychologically characterized without being assessed. People who feel affected by a process in which they have no voice. And when they object, many describe another infuriating discovery: Who is going to listen to the person who isn't the client?


There is something painfully familiar about becoming a person without a name inside a system. The point is not to equate one kind of human suffering with another. It is the terrible anonymity of being reduced to the other person in somebody else's account while consequences reach into your own life. You know your name. You know the decades behind it. You know the birthdays, illnesses, school mornings, Christmases, arguments, apologies, sacrifices and ordinary Tuesdays that made up a family. Yet inside the story determining whether you remain part of that family, you may feel as though you have become little more than a case description.


An ethics code on paper does not answer that question. Enforcement does. Accountability does. Whether a person outside the therapeutic relationship has any meaningful avenue for raising a concern does. That is an area deserving far more scrutiny than it currently receives.


And Then Social Media Arrived


The therapist isn't the only new authority in the family. There is another one sitting in nearly everyone's pocket. The algorithm.


Social media has done something unprecedented to psychological information: it has taken concepts that once required textbooks, graduate education, supervision and clinical context and placed them beside makeup tutorials, political arguments, dance videos and advertisements.


Thirty seconds. Five signs your mother is a narcissist. Seven things toxic parents say. Why going no contact is protecting your peace. Signs you were emotionally neglected.

Watch one and the algorithm learns something about you. Watch another. And another arrives. Then another.


Before long, a person may not feel as though she went searching for an explanation at all. The explanation found her. It arrived between videos from friends, advertisements and entertainment, repeated in slightly different forms by different faces until unfamiliar psychological language began to feel familiar and familiar relationships began to look different through it.


This is not imaginary. APA describes social media as involving algorithmic systems capable of shaping what users repeatedly encounter and warns that adolescents are particularly sensitive to social feedback and reinforcement while self-regulatory capacities are still developing. (apa.org)


Now put psychological certainty into that machine. And then give it to children.

That thought should stop us.


Which Brings Me to Our Grandchildren


This may be the part that frightens me most.


My generation is fighting over what psychology, therapy culture and social media have already done—or have not done—to relationships between parents and adult children. Our grandchildren are growing up inside the machine itself.


For many of them, there will be no memory of life before algorithms. No childhood before social media. No adolescence before an endless stream of strangers explained what anxiety means, what trauma means, what a narcissist looks like, what a boundary should sound like, what kind of body is desirable, what kind of relationship is healthy, what political beliefs make someone good or bad, and what kind of discomfort should never have to be tolerated.

Think about the enormity of that difference. We worried about what our children learned from television, their friends and perhaps whatever magazines they managed to sneak into the house. Our grandchildren can carry an entire world of influence into their bedrooms. It can follow them to school, sit beside them at dinner and remain inches from their faces after the adults in the house have gone to sleep.


Up to 95% of American teenagers use social media, and approximately one-third report using it almost constantly. The U.S. Surgeon General has said the available evidence does not allow us to conclude that social media is sufficiently safe for children and adolescents. (hhs.gov)


APA has warned that young people are particularly vulnerable to certain social-media content and platform features because they interact with developmental and neurological vulnerabilities. (apa.org)


And now another force has entered their lives: Artificial intelligence.


The video that first made me stop and think about this wasn't really asking whether a computer could cause estrangement. It raised a much more disturbing possibility.

What happens when a person in pain no longer has to search TikTok for validation? What happens when they can sit alone at two in the morning and tell an artificial intelligence system only their side of a relationship—and then ask: Was my mother abusive? Is my father a narcissist? Should I go no contact? Was my childhood traumatic? Am I being gaslighted?

There is something profoundly different about that interaction. Social media broadcasts. Artificial intelligence answers you. It can feel conversational, attentive and personal. It doesn't roll its eyes, interrupt, get tired of hearing the story or say, Maybe there's another way to understand what happened. The human being sitting in front of it may experience something that feels remarkably like being heard.


AI doesn't know the mother. It doesn't know the father. It wasn't at the kitchen table twenty years ago. It doesn't know what wasn't included in the prompt. And yet its response can arrive instantly, privately and in language that sounds extraordinarily authoritative.

That deserves serious research now, not twenty years from now when today's children are sitting in estrangement groups of their own.


I cannot help wondering what happens to a child's capacity for ambiguity when every uncomfortable feeling can immediately be named, explained and validated by something that sounds certain. I wonder what happens to reconciliation when an algorithm never knew the person with whom reconciliation might occur. I wonder what happens to family stories when every generation can construct its own version with a machine that has access to enormous amounts of psychological language but none of the lived history of that particular family.


Because social media was the first great experiment in allowing algorithms to mediate human relationships. AI may become the second.


And our grandchildren should not have to become the generation that tells us what the experiment did.


Something Has Gone Terribly Wrong Here


Family estrangement is often treated as though tens of thousands of unrelated families simply arrived independently at the same destination. Maybe that explanation is no longer sufficient.


Maybe we need to examine the culture surrounding those families. The therapeutic language. The changing definitions of harm. The rise of individualism. The decline of family obligation. The influence of social media. The professional training of the people interpreting family conflict. The algorithms reinforcing psychological narratives. The normalization of cutoff. And now artificial intelligence entering the most private conversations human beings have about one another.


These things did not arrive separately. They are colliding inside families at the same moment. Psychology moved into popular culture. Popular culture moved onto social media. Social media became algorithmic. Algorithms became intimate. And now artificial intelligence can participate in conversations about our deepest wounds without ever having known the people whose motives, personalities and histories are being discussed.

None of this requires us to pretend that parents never cause profound harm. It requires us to reject something equally dangerous: the assumption that every broken family can be understood simply by identifying which individual deserves the blame.


There are parents who have spent years asking themselves what they did wrong. Some have apologized for things they remember doing and things they barely remember at all. Some have read books, gone to counseling, written letters they never sent, respected boundaries they did not understand, waited through birthdays and holidays, and tried desperately to find the combination of words that might open a door without pushing against it.


Thousands upon thousands of estranged parents are already telling us that something feels profoundly different. Some of them know psychology. Some teach it. Some practice it. Some have spent careers working with families. And some are looking at what is happening now and saying: Something has gone terribly wrong here.


Maybe instead of dismissing them as angry parents who cannot accept their children's boundaries, it is time somebody listened.


Not because every parent is right.

Not because every adult child is wrong.


But because a culture that has become extraordinarily good at identifying reasons to leave relationships should also be willing to ask what we are losing when leaving becomes easier than learning how to remain connected through imperfection.


And because this isn't only about us anymore.

Our grandchildren are watching. And increasingly, something else is watching them back.


They will inherit whatever we decide family means now. They will inherit our language about harm, our ideas about boundaries, our tolerance—or intolerance—for human imperfection, our algorithms, our technology and the examples we give them for what human beings do when love and pain occupy the same relationship.


Perhaps that is why I cannot look away from this.


I am an estranged mother. I am an alienated grandmother. I know what it means to love people who are still living and yet be unable to participate in their lives. I also know that somewhere beyond all of these studies, professional debates, social-media posts and psychological terminology are real families whose photographs still sit on shelves, whose names are still spoken, whose birthdays are still remembered, and whose empty chairs are still noticed. And I will not make my son a villain in order to make my grief easier to explain. Estrangement has not erased everything I know about the good man inside him, any more than it has erased the little boy I raised, the years we shared, or the love that existed long before our relationship broke apart. I refuse to reduce him to somebody else's influence, too. He's still my son, still an adult with agency, and still the good man I remember and recognize even while I profoundly disagree with what has happened. If anything, knowing the goodness that is still there makes the loss harder to understand, not easier.


That is what can disappear when this conversation becomes nothing but terminology.

People.

Families.

History.

Love.

And children who are watching all of us learn—or fail to learn—how to live with one another when loving someone becomes complicated.


Something has gone terribly wrong here.


We should care enough about the generations coming behind us to find out what it is.

 

LISA FRANCO ALEXANDER

Founder, Heart’s Renewal

Life After Complicated Loss™

Peace · Purpose · Wholeness.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page