I Will Not Make My Son a Villain, So My Grief Makes Sense
Estrangement Changed Our Relationship. It Did Not Erase the Son I Raised.
By Lisa Franco Alexander
Yesterday, I came across a question in a parental estrangement support group that stopped me.
It asked whether, if we somehow knew with certainty that our adult child was genuinely happier and healthier without a relationship with us, would we be willing to let them go because we wanted them to be happy—even though losing them caused us enormous pain.
I didn't have to think past a split second to post my answer.
I have wanted my son's happiness since before he was old enough to tell me what happiness meant. I wanted it while I carried him, while I raised him, through childhood and adolescence, and as I watched him become his own person. His happiness mattered when his life revolved around me, and it still matters now that it doesn't.
So yes. If my son truly believes he is happier without me in his adult life, I will honor that choice. I will carry the colossal pain it causes me. I will continue loving him from a place he cannot see, and I will hold space for him in my heart without requiring him to return in order for that love to remain real.
Then someone responding to what I had written called my son selfish. Another person suggested that a man who could allow his children to lose their grandmother obviously didn't care enough about them. And something in me rose immediately.
No.
You may know that my son is estranged from his mother. You do not know my son.
I Am Still Proud of the Man He Became
There can be a strange temptation in estrangement to rewrite an entire relationship through the lens of its most painful chapter.
The child who loved us becomes selfish. The adult we admired becomes weak or uncaring. The memories become suspect. People who know almost nothing about the decades that came before the estrangement can feel surprisingly comfortable telling us who our children are.
But I knew my son before estrangement became part of our vocabulary.
I knew the little boy I raised. I knew the teenager finding his independence. I knew the young man becoming an adult. And I have watched the grown man build a life rooted in many of the qualities I hoped to instill in him.
I am not proud only of the little boy I remember. I am immensely proud of the man he is today.
My son is a firefighter and paramedic trained in technical rescue, including water and diving rescue. He chose a profession that requires him to go toward people on some of the worst days of their lives.
There are stories I could tell you about him that would make any mother burst with pride. Stories about courage, compassion, service, loss, friendship and the ways he has shown up for complete strangers and fellow firefighters.
But I won't tell them. They belong to him.
He has always been an intensely private and humble man. Long before estrangement entered our lives, he made it clear that he did not want his life displayed on social media simply because his mother was proud of him. He took his role as a public servant seriously, and I learned to take his privacy seriously too.
Estrangement did not end my respect for my son. It didn't make me say, “Well, he's not speaking to me anymore, so I can tell whatever stories I want.”
I am still his mother. I am still extremely proud of him. And I am still protective of the parts of his life he has always asked me to keep private.
Even here. Even now.
I don't need to reveal the most extraordinary things my son has done in order to prove to strangers that he is a good man. I know who he is. Perhaps that is another part of loving an adult child that estrangement does not get to take from us: we can lose access to someone's life without believing we have gained ownership of their story.
From Far Away, I Still Look for Him
Respecting my son's privacy does not mean I have stopped wanting to know about his life. It’s quite the opposite, actually.
I check the public pages connected to his profession every single day. Sometimes I am simply hoping for a glimpse of him. But there is another reason I look, and it is one I suspect that any parent whose child does dangerous work will understand. When something terrible happens, worry still fills my gut. Estrangement did not turn off that part of me.
I read the stories. I look at the photographs. I leave hearts on photographs of firefighters I have never met. I thank them for the extraordinarily selfless and heroic work they do.
But if I am completely truthful, I am also searching. I am looking for my son.
A few days ago, I saw a post about a house explosion and fire. There were twenty-one photographs from the scene. I had to look. I needed to know if my son was there, and if he was, I needed some reassurance that he was okay.
So I searched through all twenty-one photographs. Smoke. Darkness. Helmets. Turnout gear. Firefighters whose faces I couldn't see. Then, in the middle of one dark, smoky photograph, I saw it.

FRANCO.
My heart thumped. There he was.
For most people looking at that photograph, he was simply another heroic firefighter doing his job. For me, it was my son, my baby. I saw the grown man in that photograph—the firefighter, the public servant, the man whose life had become entirely his own. But somewhere inside that photograph, I also saw every age he had ever been.
I think mothers do that. Time doesn't arrange our children into neat little boxes and discard each version as they grow. Somehow, we carry them all—the baby, the little boy, the teenager, the young man, the father and the grown man standing there in the smoke.
And underneath all that massive pride was the simplest relief a mother can feel:
There you are. You're okay.
Estrangement may have changed my access to my adult child's life, but it did not switch off the part of me that worries when he might be in danger. I don't get to stop being his mother simply because I no longer get to ask him whether he made it home safely.
Yesterday, I commented on the page of a photographer who regularly captures close-up images of firefighters. I told him how much I loved his photographs and admitted that I hoped one day I might see my son among them.
He answered me.
When I told him he was a technical rescuer, he immediately named the exact station as somewhere he needed to visit more often. Then he asked what shift he worked so he could try to photograph him sometime soon.
And I didn't know. I am his mother, and I didn't know my son's shift. That is estrangement too.
It isn't only empty chairs on holidays, unanswered messages, missed birthdays and family photographs in which someone is absent. Sometimes estrangement is searching public photographs for the face you once saw across your own kitchen table.
Sometimes it is a complete stranger kindly offering to help you see your own child—and realizing you no longer know enough about his everyday life to answer a simple question.
For a moment, I felt ashamed.
How could I not know my own son's shift? And then I reminded myself of something. Not knowing my son's shift does not mean I stopped knowing my son. Estrangement changed what I am allowed to know about his life. It did not change what I know about his heart.
We Raised Them to Become Their Own People
There is something almost unbearably ironic about parenting. We spend years teaching our children how to become independent of us. We teach them to think for themselves. We teach responsibility, loyalty and commitment. We hope they will grow into adults capable of building lives of their own. If they marry, we hope they understand what it means to take that commitment seriously. If they become parents, we hope they will love their children fiercely.
We raise them to become adults whose lives no longer revolve around us.
I taught my son loyalty. I taught him faithfulness. I taught him to honor the family he would one day create. I never imagined that I might someday find myself hurting on the other side of some of those very values.
I do not have to agree with every decision he has made in order to recognize the man I raised inside those decisions. I can wish desperately that he had chosen differently. I can believe there could have been another way. I can live with tremendous pain because of what has happened between us.
And I can still refuse to call the man he has become selfish, weak, heartless or a loser simply because those words might make my grief easier to explain.
Pain does not require a villain in order to be real.
And Then There Are My Grandchildren
This is where the original question becomes harder for me.
My adult child has agency over his relationship with me, however painful his decision may be. But my grandchildren had a relationship with me too.
Before the estrangement, their Daddy regularly told me how happy he was that his children had me in their lives. He saw how excited they were when I was coming over. He knew they asked for me. He knew how close we were and how deeply we loved one another. He was happy about it. Those memories did not disappear simply because our circumstances changed.
After the estrangement, there were times when we found ourselves in the same public hockey arena, where my grandchildren could see me, and I could see them. My little Emmie would bury her face against her daddy's side and cry. Joshy would sometimes try to sneak a little wave to me across the arena.
And there stood their father, my son. The same man who had once told me how happy it made him that his children were so close to their Grammie.
I will not tell you what was going through his mind in those moments because I don't know. I will not claim to know another human being's private thoughts simply because I am his mother. But I know what he saw.
He saw his daughter cry. He saw his son trying to acknowledge his grandmother from across the arena. He saw me standing on the other side of a relationship that had once been completely ordinary. And he had to stand there too.
That is why I cannot accept the easy explanation that my adult child simply does not care. I cannot tell you exactly what he carries. I can only tell you that I refuse to fill what I do not know with resentment.
“My Mom Is Missing”
There is another memory I carry.
My entire immediate and closest multi-generational family very recently gathered for a reunion I had not been told about. People traveled to be together, and I wasn't there. My son noticed.
“My Mom is missing.”
Four words.
They did not repair our estrangement. They did not bring my grandchildren back into my life. They did not undo the pain of discovering that people I loved had gathered without me.
But those words mattered to me. Because I was missing. Not simply absent. Missing.
I Don't Need to Condemn Him to Acknowledge What Happened
Sometimes reducing someone to a villain would make grief easier.
If I could convince myself that my son was simply a terrible person, perhaps I wouldn't miss him in quite the same way. If I could decide that he had never really loved me, that our closeness wasn't real, that the memories were meaningless and that everything I believed about his character had been wrong, perhaps there would be less left to grieve. But doing that would require me to rewrite my own life. And I won't. My son is not only the man who is estranged from me.
He is also the baby I carried, the child I raised, the young man I watched become independent, the husband who made promises to the woman he chose, the father who once delighted in watching his children love their grandmother, and the public servant whose face his mother still searches for in photographs taken by strangers.
He is all of those people. And I am still his mother.
There are moments when remembering him makes me smile so deeply that I can almost feel the warmth of those years again. And there are moments when the very same memories leave me crying so hard I can barely catch my breath. Neither reaction makes the other one less true. That is what complicated loss can look like. Love did not disappear when the relationship did.
I Will Not Rewrite the Son I Raised
So I return to the question that started all of this.
If I somehow knew with certainty that my son was genuinely happier and healthier without me in his life, would I let him go?
Yes.
Not because losing him doesn't hurt. Not because I believe everything that has happened was right. Not because the relationship between my grandchildren and me didn't matter. And certainly not because I stopped being his mother.
I would honor his choice because his life belongs to him. But there is something else I will do. I will remember.
I will remember the child before the estrangement. I will remember the years that were good. I will remember the laughter, the ordinary days, the accomplishments, the conversations and the thousands of moments that nobody commenting beneath a social-media post could possibly know.
There was a reason the words “my baby” came so naturally when I saw that photograph. I used to tell my son that no matter how old he became—even when he was an old man—he would always be my baby. My grandchildren knew I called their daddy that too.
One day Joshy asked me, “Grammie, Daddy is a grown-up. Why do you call him baby?” “Because grown-up Daddy is still my baby. Always.”
The kids thought that was hilarious. Sometimes when their daddy called them down for dinner while I was there, they would tease him: “Okay, Grammie's baby. We're coming! ” We laughed about it then.
I don't think I understood how much those silly little moments would someday mean to me. My son grew up, exactly as he was supposed to. He became a man, a husband, a father, a firefighter, a person with a life entirely his own. But motherhood never required me to stop seeing all the ages that came before.
I will remember the man my son showed himself to be over a lifetime rather than allowing one painful chapter to become the definition of the entire book.
I will leave room for what I cannot know about his experience. I will respect the parts of his life that are his to keep private. I will continue being proud of him, even when he never knows that I am. I will grieve what happened without requiring myself to condemn the person I am grieving. And I will continue learning how to build a life of my own while carrying love for someone who is no longer participating in it. Because estrangement has already taken enough from us.
It does not get to take every beautiful thing that came before it, too.
LISA FRANCO ALEXANDER
Founder, Heart’s Renewal
Life After Complicated Loss™
Peace · Purpose · Wholeness.





Comments