top of page
Search

Estrangement Has Taken Enough

Writer: lisa62143
lisa62143
Oct 6
3 min read

When Pain Begins Turning Into Anger—and Anger Begins Changing the Room



By Lisa Franco Alexander


Over the past several weeks, I have spent more time inside online communities for estranged parents and alienated grandparents. I went there for the same reason many people do: I am one of them. I know the excruciating pain of loving children and grandchildren who are still living while no longer being part of their lives.


But something else has been impossible not to notice.


These spaces can become incredibly angry places.


Some of that anger begins when people enter communities created for hurting parents and grandparents seemingly for the purpose of telling them that they caused their own estrangement, deserved what happened, or need to examine themselves before they are entitled to grieve. In the groups I frequent, the attacks I have encountered have repeatedly come through anonymous posts or accounts using names that reveal little about the person behind them.


Then, almost as if someone else had been watching the same room, I saw a post from psychologist Dr. Joshua Coleman, whose work on family estrangement I have written about before. He reminded readers that his online community exists to support estranged parents and grandparents who are in enormous pain and need kindness, support and empathy. It was not, he wrote, a place to blame people for being estranged or to give unwanted advice. Comments and participants who could not offer kindness and support would be removed.


I stopped when I read it.


Because I knew exactly why a message like that had become necessary.


What struck me was that the warning had become necessary at all. A space created specifically for people living with estrangement had reached a point where its purpose had to be restated: this is a place for support, not blame. There are other rooms for examining what happened. There are rooms for accountability, therapy, reconciliation, anger and hard questions. But if every room becomes a courtroom, eventually there is nowhere left simply to hurt.


But there is another part of this conversation that troubles me just as much. I have watched hurting parents and grandparents become so angry at the people who enter these spaces to condemn them that sometimes the anger begins changing them, too. Words like evil, parasites, narcissists, bottom-feeders and broken brains begin appearing. People wish future estrangement upon strangers so they will someday understand the pain they are causing.


I understand the anger. I live with estrangement too. I understand what it is to miss people who are still alive and to carry love that suddenly has nowhere to land.


But I don't want estrangement to teach me cruelty.


And that is when I think we have to ask ourselves a very difficult question:


What is estrangement turning us into?


A support group is not a courtroom. Nobody should have to prove that they were a perfect parent before they are permitted to hurt. Nobody has to establish that their adult child was entirely wrong before they are permitted to grieve. Listening to someone's pain does not require us to issue a verdict about everything that happened inside their family. We do not have to know every detail of another person's family history to say, I don't know everything that happened between you and your child, but I can see that losing them has broken your heart, and I can sit beside you while it hurts.


But support cannot mean giving ourselves permission to become cruel either.


That belief is also at the heart of the Still Whole Circle, the free online peer-to-peer support group I volunteer to facilitate for people experiencing family estrangement. It is a space built around something remarkably simple: listening without judgment, advice or trying to fix one another. People may share, or simply listen. Sometimes what a hurting person needs most is not an answer. It is a room where they can finally say what hurts and know they have been heard.


Perhaps that is the line we have to protect from both directions. People should not enter spaces created for hurting families simply to blame and attack them. And those of us who are hurting cannot allow those attacks—or even the estrangement itself—to turn us into people we no longer recognize.


I think about this often because forgiveness is deeply important to me. It does not mean pretending nothing happened. It does not require reconciliation. It certainly does not mean I never become angry. For me, it means refusing to allow somebody else's choices to determine what eventually lives inside me.


Estrangement has already taken relationships, birthdays, holidays, grandchildren, traditions, photographs that can no longer be updated, and futures many of us once assumed would be ours.


It does not get to take our humanity too.


Lisa Franco Alexander

Founder, Heart’s Renewal

Life After Complicated Loss™

Peace · Purpose · Wholeness.

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page